THIS REVIEW IS FOR THE NEW TONYS IN CLINTON ***Same name. New management.***
I stopped in after work for a small salad. I usual order a large, however I have not yet ordered food since it’s reopening and was unsure of the quality.
I’m glad I did not order the large.
1st- I called in the order for a small antipasto salad with NO cheese. The young lady on the phone told me “it’s ready now and I could head on over”.
2nd- when I arrived I gave my name, the girl walk over to the cooler a pulled out a salad and gave it to me. WITH CHEESE.
Now, I called in my order to insure it was fresh AND had no cheese. FAIL!
The lettuce was old and had that slimy, welty, texture. It had clearly been there probably since it’s opening. Not a great start Tony’s!
I used to love here because there slice pizza was super crispy and good, but now that i tried it again is very tick and saggy! I guess they changed their chef or something! The slice was not hot either, warm toward cold! Hopefully there old style comes back so I can come back again for there crispy new york style pizzas!! The are super nice staff and very friendly.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Recommended dishes
Wings
NY style Pizza kind of thick for the style 🍕 They have slice pizza , We try last year this pizza ans it was very good and crispy but I think they change the chef because its not as good as before🍕 wings are good and crispy. They have prep pastas to go ,never try them but they look good . Service is good they are nice ppl .
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–10
Recommended dishes
Wings
I really wanted this place to be my go to pizza place as pizza in Clinton leaves much to be desired. Heavy on the cheese and soggy to boot. The pizza used to be crispy and thin. Invest in a pizza chef .
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–10
This was a take out. We heard it was under new ownership so wanted to try it out. We were so disappointed. First why do you cut a round 16"pizza into squares? We had two pizzas cut this way just ruins the experience because there are small pieces of just crust. However the pizza was not fully cooked so the pieces in the center were barely brown on the bottom and impossible to pick up to eat because they were soggy. Overall both pizzas were under cooked. The pepperoni pizza has about 15 pieces and they were not spread evenly but clumped and with the square cut there were pieces that had no pepperoni on them. So after the disappointment of the pizza, the wings were also disappointing. They are expensive at $1.40 per wing. For that price I expected meaty wings and they were not. They did not include Blue cheese or celery. The service at pick up was fine. However, need on this experience I would not order from them again.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 2
Service: 4
Roast beef sub, dry roll, seemed day old. Meat tasted old and on its way out. Won't order there again. Much better under previous ownership.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 1
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 2
This is my first time at a Tony's Pizza place. The inside was recently refinished and is under new management. I bought a 16" Chicken bacon ranch pizza. Flavor was OK, both the chicken and the bacon were cut into large chunks (that required being cut in half), so there was no meat in the majority of our bites (typically the chicken is cubed in smaller chunks and bacon is pre-cooked to eliminate the excess grease and it is then crumbled across the whole pizza ensuring toppings in every bite). The crust was mushy (even when reheated in an air fryer). The box was totally soaked in grease. Probably from cooking the bacon on the pizza, instead of it being pre-cooked and the grease drained. Then to top it off, the ROUND pizza was cut in SQUARES! Typical cut of a round pizza is pie shape, unless otherwise stated. I didn't know they expect everyone to eat their pizza's with a fork and knife. Taking all things into consideration, needless to say, it was our first and last time eating at Tony's! I tried to add a photo of the pizza and box but I kept receiving an error.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 2
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 4
Ordered online and paid. When picking they made that person pay again because they didn't keep track it was paid for. They fixed it after we brought it to their attention, but still... The food is pretty good...just bugs to work out I hope!
Service
Take out
Food: 4
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 3
Worse steak sub I have ever had. Ordered onions and peppers it has one onion and one pepper. The steak itself was dry. Will not order there again.
Price per person
$20–30
This review is for the new owner ship. The prices are off the charts. Food quality isn’t there. Large pepperoni pizza 30 wings. 64 bucks. Unreal !! Never again.
Price per person
$50–100
Food: 2
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 4
Recommended dishes
Wings
