My wife and I went for lunch on a Sunday as every bagel shop should be busy we were able to secure a table with a view of the kitchen production . I ordered a Roast Beef on rye that was passable for a $7.99 sandwich and my wife had an ET with veggie cc on the side. Unfortunately our nearness to the kitchen shocked us with a view of a employee operating multiple microwaves like a orchestrated musician heating up liquid eggs , Bacon and melting cheese. As an X deli owner of over 20 years including 10 years in the Bagel Business I found it excruciatingly difficult to see all the happy faces enjoying their microwaved breakfast.
Gordon Ramsey would not be happy.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Breakfast
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 2
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 3
The bagels are on the small side if you compare to what you would.get in northern New Jersey or NYC. Also they cook there breakfast food in a microwave. I was not impressed with microwaved eggs taste rubbery
Service
Take out
Meal type
Breakfast
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
The drive through window was convenient. Delicious jalapeno, egg and cheese bagel. The only downside is that they do not have turkey sausage.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Amazingly impressed by The Bagel Bakery. They had a great selection of bagels, pastries, and sandwiches. I choose to get a pastrami sandwich on a jalapeño bagel with pepperjack cheese. I can't say enough about how perfectly cooked the bagel was and how great the pastrami was. The crumb cake was also fantastic.
The staff was amazing and attentive. I appreciated the extra input that I should heat up my pastrami. Came out amazing!
It's very busy, but the line went quick and without any sacrifice of quality or service.
The best part is that the prices are still reasonable and I didn't feel like I spent am arm and a leg to get a quick meal.
They have a drive thru as well (didn't know until I came in) so check that out as well if you're in a hurry.
Really delish variety of bagels and sandwiches!
Now if people would order ahead before hitting the drive through, that would be great! Inside is always a great option! Friendly staff! Great food!
We are from Buffalo NY visiting family...The Bagel Bakery was highly recommended..and it did not disappoint..The bagels are delicious and the bagel sandwiches are fresh and yummy...Staff is friendly, service is quick even if it's busy..
Will be a must visit whenever we are in town!!!
This place is the hidden gem of Hampstead. It feels like you are walking into a New Jersey bakery with Taylor pork roll and all! The prices were excellent as well.
Deliciously Consistent. Best place around for bagels. Service is always quick and friendly. We always get the breakfast sandwiches and have been unable to make ourselves try the lunch menu because they are perfect. Which is oddly disappointing but satisfying at the same time. 😊 You must go, you will not find better.
Amazing!!!! My girls wanted bagels so we went this morning. It was the best bagels we’ve had in a while. Way better than the chains out there. So much lox on my bagel too. Cream cheese is so creamy and delicious. Bonus it’s right down the street from our house. We will definitely be back! Thank you so much.
