I absolutely love Sarah’s and go often- usually a couple of times a week. This is an awesome family business with excellent coffee, sandwiches, pastries and cakes!
Service
Dine in
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
The best part is the daily variety of flavored coffee. The pastries are also really good, and the staff is friendly.
Service
Take out
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Recommended dishes
Danish
A great stop. A wonderful selection of in-house handmade homemade cakes and pastries. Fresh made sandwiches that were a delight. Family owned and operated.
I started coming to this lovely place after moving here and it has become my go-to place for breakfast and lunch whenever I feel like getting out of the house. Their breakfast sandwiches are legitimately the best I've ever had around here and their lunch sandwiches are to die for, especially the "Hot Tom." I love their baked goods too, with their muffins and eclairs being my personal favorites. They had apple muffins once too and they were well worth the try.
I decided to try their hummus and pretzels recently, and Katrina was super nice and helpful, she told me about the flavors they have and made a suggestion on the flavor to try. She was even kind enough to quickly whip up some more hummus of the suggested flavor when it turned out there was none left with the rest.
The staff are always friendly and I love getting to chat with them whenever I go in, they make me feel welcome and it's super nice being recognized when I stop in, it shows that they actually care about their customers.
Edit: Their apple crumble pie is absolutely amazing, too!
We will not be back to Sarah's. My husband and I were on a road trip from Buffalo, NY. We stopped at a bakery very near by which we spent nearly $100. and decided to pop in for a cheesecake. We felt very uncomfortable and the people behind the counter seemed unapproachable. We just chalked it up to not being a regular. Please stop by the bakery, they were amazing. I am sorry I didn't read reviews first.
