Rolling Pin Bakery in Setauket
Owner not registered
More details
Price & Cuisine
$
Bakery
Establishment type
Bakery
Features
Reviews
90
reviews
Sorting
Date
Date From - Date To
Source:
10
3 months ago
Rolling Pin Bakery was fantastic! The wedding cake tasted amazing and looked beautiful. I showed them a picture of what I envisioned our wedding cake to be and they knocked it out of the park. They also helped with last minute questions and I was able to send them the type of edible pearl decoration I wanted to use. Highly recommend!
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$100+
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes
Cake Samples
Source:
10
4 months ago
I can’t say enough good things about this bakery, we called at 6:30 am for a same day pick up for a close friends baby homecoming from the hospital. Because we didn’t have much time we didn’t expect much except for a pink cake with the message we selected written on it. Wow when I say how impressed we were with the final product ..it’s still an understatement! They took such great care to decorate the cake with a baby girl theme and once we actually ate the cake it was equally delicious ! Our friends were so touched that we got them such a gorgeous cake to commemorate their newborns homecoming! Order your special occasion cake here !!
Source:
10
2 years ago
The Rolling Pin Bakery was the bakery that worked with our venue for the wedding cake. We had heard wonderful things about Rolling Pin but had never tried anything from them. Due to planning during COVID we did not do any sort of cake-testing and chose our cake at one of our meetings with our venue. We wanted to do a burgundy piping on the cake and the bakery reached out the week prior to our wedding to ask if we wanted to change the color because there was humid and wet weather in the weekend forecast. We were so appreciative of them being proactive and reaching out to us so that our wedding cake did not “sweat” and the colors did not run. When we saw the cake it was perfect and when we, and our guests, ate the cake we were blown away by the fabulous flavor! It was the best cake we ever had, we will certainly recommend the Rolling Pin Bakery to our friends and order from them for our next bakery needs!
Source:
10
A year ago
I had the most amazing & beautiful bridal shower last weekend at The Smithtown Landing Country Club. I can’t thank my wonderful Mother enough for everything she did to make this day so special, she put her heart & soul into my bridal shower to make every little detail perfect.
She had my cake made here and it was gorgeous and delicious! Everyone couldn’t stop talking about how yummy it was. My mom showed the bakery a picture of a cake she had found on Pinterest that she had in mind and the cake this bakery made came out even better than the one on Pinterest.
My mom said everyone at the bakery was extremely kind and so helpful!
My fiancé and I are also having this bakery make our wedding day cake and we can’t wait!
Source:
10
3 months ago
Ordered a 1/2 sheet gluten free cake for my son's engagement party & it was delicious! The raspberry jam filling was so good also!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Source:
10
A year ago
The cake was delicious! People we shocked that my wedding cake was funfetti 😂. It was absolutely stunning as well. Really just breathtaking to look at.
Source:
10
3 years ago
Ordered cake along with cookies as party favors for my mother’s 80th birthday. It was all beautiful, fresh and delicious. I saw a few comment about little cake versus a lot of filling and that was not the case with this cake. It was perfectly balanced. Thanks Rolling Pin!
Source:
10
4 months ago
There is a reason why this place is always packed. The food is the freshest and healthiest option I have found in bergen County.
On a side note, I do deliveries and just recently i accidentally picked up the wrong order by mistake (my fault), i ended up getting deactivated over the misunderstanding.
I called the owner and he was SO nice and really cared about me losing my job. He assured me that he "would not let that happen." He made some phone calls and I got my job back!
It is VERY rare to get your job back once you get deactivated, but thanks to his kind heart and his help i got it back almost immediately. Thank you!
P.S.
Come to thr rolling pin in Westwood nj for a delicious homemade healthy breakfast or lunch!
Source:
10
2 years ago
We stopped by to pick up a loaf of bread but couldn't resist the pastries. On of the best pastries I've ever tried. The pastry crust was so tender it literally melted in your mouth. The peaches taste like they were picked this morning. Wish I could try one of everything.
Source:
10
2 years ago
Always a delicious assortment of cookies and pastries to choose from. The display case cakes are always beautiful and fresh. We've ordered many specialty cakes from here for birthdays and other occasions and are always impressed by the quality and detail put into the cake's taste and design. The Rolling Pin has been a community staple for ages and there'd a reason why!
Does this bellong to you?