Pymatuning Pizza Pizzeria in Pymatuning Central

Name: Pymatuning Pizza
Address: 1837 PA-285, Pymatuning Central, United States
Telephone: 17246290088
Rating: 3.5

Owner not registered

Main

United States

Establishments

Pymatuning Pizza

Reviews

#5 From 5 in Pymatuning Central

10 Review

Ambience

7/10

Food

7/10

Interior

7/10

Prices

7/10

Service

7/10

More details

Price & Cuisine

$$ Pizza

Establishment type

Pizzeria

Features

Seating

Wheelchair Accessible

Information

1837 PA-285, Pymatuning Central, United States

Get direction

Website Pymatuning Pizza

About

Nicely cooked Pepperoni, chicken and salads will impress you at the first bite. At this pizzeria, you can order dishes as a takeaway. From the guests' viewpoint, prices are average. But google users haven't given Pymatuning Pizza a high rating.

Rating

Excellent

Very Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

Sorting

Newest

Oldest

Ascending rating

Descending rating

Date

Date From - Date To

Mark Laughs

Source:

6 months ago

Don't let this place fool you! Hands down the best pizza in Pennsylvania! I'll be there again soon to see if the taste repeats! Meal type Dinner Price per person $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 3

Chris Wagner

Source:

8 months ago

I recently called and tried to order a 12 inch plain cheese pizza , thin crust and was told the price was 15.80. I said to the girl, 16.00 for a 12” plain cheese pizza and she said yes. This went back and forth 3 or 4 times before I told her I didn’t want to place an order, and I said the menu says 10.00 on Facebook post from like 3 days ago. Even if she thought I wanted gluten free crust and extra cheese, it would only be 13.00, of which I wanted neither….I could have asked for someone else but at that point I thought if I was questioning it and she wasn’t checking with someone else to verify, why bother. I would say either train better or update your pricing on your menu. I was disappointed because I know that couldn’t be right and I was looking forward to trying this place. Service: 1

LakeGirl Traveling

Source:

8 months ago

We ordered two pizzas - one with a pan crust and one with a thin crust. BOTH were very thick and one was undercooked. It's very conveniently located, but not sure we'll order here again.The folks at the counter were pleasant. Service Take out Meal type Dinner Price per person $20–30 Food: 3 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 3

Carrie Atkinson-Weber

Source:

9 months ago

Got an 8 cut pizza with pepperoni, onions and mushrooms. Total came to almost $32.00. Had barely any sauce, very little toppings but a ton of cheese. Definitely not worth the money. We will not be back. Service Take out Meal type Dinner Price per person $10–20

Ben Kosewski

Source:

A year ago

If you like thick, doughy pizza, this is your place. I did order the thin pizza option. But it was pillowy, which is fine, but wasn’t expected when I thought it was going to be much thinner. Service Take out Meal type Dinner Price per person $10–20

Dan Barr

Source:

A year ago

Good pizza! Love the different Buffalo Chicken, comparing to Pgh! Fluffy and flavorful pie! Service Take out Meal type Dinner Price per person $50–100

Cheri Eiduke

Source:

A year ago

Cool old building. Great feel to the building. I love a good deep dish. They are hard to find. The pizza was a good mix of toppings and bread. Not skimpy with the sauce. I imagine they use good quality pans as the center was not raw or doughy with either of our pizza. I was in Andover to get something from the library and saw someone else's review. That brought me here. I wish I lived closer. I would be a regular Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Kara C

Source:

A year ago

Really good pizza. It was quick and delicious, made with good ingredients. I really like pan crust, it was thick but not doughy. Staff was pleasant. I’ll definitely be going back, would like to try their subs. Service Take out Meal type Dinner Price per person $10–20

J G

Source:

A year ago

Updated : I have been back and the pizza was delicious, it has a good taste will stop back again . I talked to the owner and I'm sorry it took me this long to get back I'm sad to say my first experience here was bad. I went in and ordered, paid , and said my order would be ready in a half hour . I returned and they never made my pizza, I got my money back , but it was too late for us to go anywhere else . I hope if I come back it is a better

Holly Miller

Source:

2 years ago

Honestly sadly disappointed. It was our first time ordering from here. We order 2 extra large pepperoni pizza’s. Both our pizzas were burnt, we only got 2 pieces of pepperoni on each piece of pizza and the pizza was extremely greasy. I hope this was just a one time fluke. Not sure what everyone else’s experiences have been. 😞😞

Does this bellong to you?