I live for pizza and I’ve tried many pizza places in NoCo. The pizza was out of this world. The crust was so flavorful and had the perfect light crispy layer. I haven’t had this kind of crust since the east coast. I ordered the Main Street, so so good. They do not skimp on toppings! Every bite was a home run. Best part, the pizza wasn’t flimsy and held its structure with each bite. I also ordered the breadsticks. This shop knows how to make good bread, so so good. The marinara was a bit disappointing. The sauce had the consistency of salsa, watery and intense onion flavor. Definitely felt like I was eating salsa with my bread. The sauce worked with the bread, but I would’ve enjoyed a true marinara sauce that’s traditionally thick and robust flavor. Overall, I will be back here ordering pizza. Definitely found my new fave pizza spot.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Great food, great price, quick delivery!
We ordered around 6pm on a Wednesday, and expected at least an hour for delivery, but it arrived in about 45 minutes. Everything was hot, well packaged, and smelled incredible.
Because this was our first time ordering, we ordered several small items to try.
We had boneless wings, pizza rolls, a calzone, a spicy chicken ranch pizza, and a cookie sandwich. The breading was a little soft on the wings, but that's not unusual with a delivery. The dough for both the calzone and the pizza rolls is delicious! The pizza rolls almost remind me of a mall food court pretzel stuffed with pepperoni and cheese.
The pizza was also great. The seasoning on the chicken mixed with the ranch and banana peppers gave a great balanced flavor with a touch of spice.
A couple reviews mentioned the marinara being too thin or too bland - I disagree. It is full of spices and seasonings and the perfect consistency for dipping the pizza rolls or calzones into.
The only negative was the cookie sandwich, which isn't made by pizza street anyway - the cookies were very bland and dry even with the frosting, and the frosting didn't have any flavor. It mostly just tasted like whipped butter. But we didn't order for the cookies, so that wasn't a real issue.
Overall we were very happy with our order, and we'll be ordering again. I want to try the sandwiches next time!
Service
Delivery
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
I placed my order at 5:35 online. The estimated pick up time was 20 min. I come from Fort Collins so 20 min is about how long it takes for me to get there ( it did state online times were estimates and could change). When we arrived it was right at 6:00 o'clock. We were told it would be another 30 min, then the guy said it would only be 20 min. 20 min later they started our order so we ended up waiting 40 minutes total. The time from when i ordered till I left was a little over an hour. I realize they were busy, but an apology for the long wait would have made a big difference. When we got home I was eating my first pizza roll and something poked the inside of my mouth. I took it out of my mouth and it was a piece of plastic. I just put that pizza roll aside and grabbed the next one, got about half way through and got my mouth poked again, another piece of plastic. After the long wait and the plastic in 2 pizza rolls, i couldn't eat anymore. Things are usually pretty good, but this time was very disappointing, especially since i paid almost 30 dollars with gratuity. Definitely not worth the money this time.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 3
Amazing. Good prices great food huge menu and always super friendly workers. Mom and pop shop vibe
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–10
Recommended dishes
Highway 160 Calzone
Great food! Pizza roll special on Sunday is awesome and usually pretty quick delivery. Pizza and sandwiches are always tasty, have never tried anything here that I didn't like.
Service
Take out
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were craving some calzones the other night so we figured we'd give Pizza Street a try. We ended up having it delivered since we weren't in the mood to drive. We got our food within about 45 minutes which wasn't bad at all seeing as we live a decent distance from their restaurant. We were so excited to finally eat because it smelt so good! Unfortunately, we were left pretty disappointed when we saw how tiny they were. These were the smallest calzones we've ever seen, especially when they were $14 a piece. Taste wise, they weren't bad, but definitely not the best we've had either. The marinara sauce was also extremely watered down and relatively bland. Overall, it wasn't terrible, but I don't think we'd ever order from here again.
Service
Delivery
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Beau Joes likes to claim that they are Colorado pizza when in all reality you’re eating a loaf of bread with very little of anything. This place is one of the best for what I would claim to fame as “Colorado pizza”. This is Colorado Pizza in my opinion it is so freshly done every day by the chef in the back that I just cannot wait to order every time. this is by far the only pizza that is refrigerator friendly and is by far even better cold or the next day! I swear try it! The breadsticks are amazing you definitely should get them. We always get a pepperoni mushroom and black olives and really that’s the only thing I’ll ever order for the rest of my life. We may be a little biased because we live two minutes away but I think everyone should just stop by and try it for themselves!
Was in the mood for pizza so tried this local place.
The pizza that we ordered was The bbq chicken pizza. The crust was just ok, seemed it needed a little salt and a bit longer in the oven. The bbq sauce was tasty though and definitely heavy on the toppings, maybe why I thought some oven time was needed.
The mango habanero chicken bites had good flavor but the chicken was a bit soggy where I prefer them crispy.
We tried the cookies as well. Those were good although definitely should be split in half and shared.
Overall it was just ok.
Service
Delivery
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
First time trying a calzone in Colorado since I moved here and it was pretty good! I got the highway 160 and I love the cream sauce. It’s huge for a medium, I should’ve got the small size. The marinara sauce is yummy too! Excited to try their other food options
Service
Delivery
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 4
Service: 5
Chef salad is hearty and delicious! We also ordered the calzones. We had the Highway calzones. Outside is toasty. The only regret I have is not ordering more toppings. Wonderful dinner on Valentine's Day. Thank you Pizza Street! ❤
