The South Jersey Legend!
YES … it’s in a giant flea market
YES … it’s only open Thu-Sun
EDIT 2023:
I was in the area and stopped for lunch.
First the guy behind the counter yelled at the only customer waiting because the customer was on the “pickup” side instead of the “order” side.
Very “soup n@zi” vibes.
So after the guy took the order I requested a couple slices and a drink and the guy barked at me “card is $10 minimum “
Okay, no problem. But there’s no reason to be a jerk about it. I thought hefty guys were supposed to be jolly?
Maybe the pizza is still good but clearly the attention has gone to their head, I chose to get lunch elsewhere.
YES … it’s CASH ONLY
YES … it’s in the middle of NOWHERE
YES … it’s a legit TOMATO PIE
YES … it’s awesome!
Does it have the pillowy goodness of L&B, or the 3D magic of Mancini Pizza? No. But it’s still yummy!
Atmosphere: 1
Square pie with cheese then sauce. Easier to call ahead. Typical wait time is 20-30 minutes. It's the perfect car pizza. By that I mean you open the hatch of your suv or mini van and stand outside leaning forward so you don't dribble sauce all over your clothes. Bring a roll of paper towels! This pizza never makes it out of the parking lot. It's good hot or cold. I grab a pie every time I visit the flea market.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Other
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Always take out (I always call ahead for pick up). Ready in 20 minutes, $20 cash. Honestly, it's the best pizza I've ever eaten, and it reminds me of pizza in Italy. I'm not kidding. Get a pie and see what all of the fuss is about.
Service
Take out
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
I have eaten Pete’s Pizza all of my life. I prefer it over any other pizza from anywhere! Keep up the good work, Pete’s!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
The best thing about moving back to NJ is my favorite childhood pizza place 😩❤️ I drove an extra 20 minutes out of the way to treat myself! The pizza is delicious as always and the customer service is always great!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Recommended dishes
Sicilian Pizza
I’m very confused. There’s no cheese. Only sauce and it tastes like Campbells tomato soup. I have never in my life seen pizza served with no cheese. When we first opened the box I really thought they mixed the order up with someone who ordered a pie with no cheese. Actually couldn’t eat it and had to throw out. First time I’ve never enjoyed pizza. How does this guy have a pizza shop?
I love there pizza, it is like a tomato pie. I ask for mine to be crispy. If I am at the Columbus Farmers Market, I am stopping at Pete's. Not as cheesy as other places. Oh and you have to try the birch beer! FYI that this place does not have water.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
BEST PIZZA IN NEW JERSEY! and I've tried A LOT! Been going here every Sunday for the past 10 years. Pizza sauce is one of a kind and the slices are nice and thick. I can't stand the typical New York razor thin slices that taste like cardboard out of a brick oven. Reasonable prices too! (Haven't raised consistently due to inflation). Awesome friendly staff. pretty much the only pizza I'll eat. :)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Best. Tomato. Pies. EVER! Pretty much one of the only reasons to go to Columbus Market. Always hot and fresh. Whole pies (10 slices) are about 18 dollars and a half pie is I believe 11 dollars. Make sure to wash it all down with some red cream soda. Once you get one of their pizzas you become a regular!
