Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62732396

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62732884

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62732280

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62733052

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62732986

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62733144

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62732909

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62731831

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62732869

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62732944

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62731879

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62731785

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62731984

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62732682

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62732577

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62733184

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62731777

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62732000

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62731754

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom photo-62733047

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Restaurant,Pizzeria,Bar in Greeley

Name: Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
Address: 2349 W 29th St, Greeley, United States
Telephone: 19703301116
Rating: 2.9

Owner not registered

Main

United States

Establishments

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Reviews

#190 From 285 in Greeley

5.8

10 Review

Ambience

5.8/10

Food

5.8/10

Interior

5.8/10

Prices

5.8/10

Service

5.8/10

More details

Price & Cuisine

$$ American, Bar, Pizza

Establishment type

Restaurant, Pizzeria, Bar

Dietary Restrictions

Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free, Vegan Options

Information

+19703301116

2349 W 29th St, Greeley, United States

Get direction

Website Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

About

Come to this bar for a break and degust nicely cooked chicago pizza, cheese sticks and pies. The truth is that you will really like good biscuits and tasty Brezeln. It might be nice to enjoy delicious craft beer, ale or draft beer. You will be offered great lemonade. Food delivery is a big plus of Old Chicago. Most users indicate that the staff is hospitable. This place is notable for its spectacular service. From the visitors' viewpoint, prices are attractive. The nice atmosphere might make you want to stay here for a bit longer than you've initially planned. Google users awarded this spot 4.1.

Rating

Excellent

Very Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

Sorting

Newest

Oldest

Ascending rating

Descending rating

Date

Date From - Date To

Ryan DeHart

Source:

6 days ago

Everyone who has waited in us when we visit has been amazing. It's nice to see that they hire good workers that stick around. The food is also kicka**! Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Price per person $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes Side Salad

Aliana Garza

A month ago

I ordered the Chicken Parmesan pasta, the chicken comes on top of the pasta and it was super burnt when it came out so I had the take it back a recook it, they bring it back out and it was even more burnt and super hard to cut. Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Price per person $10–20 Food: 1 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5

Jamie Eberle

3 months ago

Walked into the bar, sat ourselves in the bar as we usually do, because we’ve never been told it was wait to be seated. Sat for 15 minutes, no waitress. This waitress that looked Wednesday Adam’s passed by 10 times and never said a word. So finally I ask, “can we get a waitress”? She said, “well I thought you guys had been here since you sat where there were dirty dishes”. She appeared to be the only server as the other one was tied up with a party in the private room. It was not that busy. She grabbed the dishes rolled her eyes and walked off. We decided since she already had an attitude we would probably get terrible service the rest of the night for the Sunday night game. As we are walking out I hear her tell the hostess, “well they sat themselves at a dirty booth so whatever”. I turn around and said “well we sat there because it was the only booth available”. The very young unprofessional hostess started pointing at the half wiped off sign and said, “it’s not seat yourself. I said “well every time we’ve come to this bar it has been”. So she decided to repeat herself and said it again an escalated voice while pointing at the sign. Almost every time we come here lately, your whole waitstaff is nothing but rude. We spend a lot of money and tip very well when we have been there and Adrian is our server (she is the only good one). We will not be back! Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Price per person $100+ Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

Israel Mares

Taylor is the absolute best. She's an extremely hard worker and is an amazing waitress. She remembers drinks and food orders for us regulars, that says a lot about her. She always makes us feel welcome and as long as we have Taylor, we'll always be customers. Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Price per person $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls

Andy Duncan

If it wasn't for the excellent bartenders and servers, I would not come into this place... I've been a regular here and have loved coming here for 20+ years. However, recent corporate policies and inconsistent management have led to my frequency of attendance to be less and less. The bartenders that I have enjoyed over the years and a few of the servers, are literally, the only reason I still frequent this establishment at all. Service Dine in Meal type Lunch Price per person $20–30 Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 1 Recommended dishes GS BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger

Ernesto Casas

4 months ago

The pizza roll appetizer was great, fries were good but hamburger was not good at all but not bad enough for me to send back or make a fuss(my roommate’s dog didn’t complain). Service was good, waitress was friendly and the atmosphere was the same as a Chili’s/Applebee’s. Would go back but I wouldn’t order a hamburger from here, looking to try their other options though! Service Dine in Meal type Lunch Price per person $10–20 Food: 3 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4

Ken Wachter

I cannot comment on atmosphere since my order was take out. However, the woman that brought my food to me was very nice. The food on the other hand was horrible. I got an order of wings for $11.99 and received 5 wings!! They were very tough and not much flavor at all. I also got a large cheese pizza with original thick crust. That was the worst pizza I have ever had. Not only was the crust plain with absolutely no flavor or seasoning, they barely put any sauce on it which made it so dry that I couldn't eat it. Along with a drink, my bill was $37. It was the the worst dinner I have had in a long time for that much money. Will not return. Food: 1 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 1

Shantae Duran

5 months ago

You do realize you are in Broncos Country, right? Play the Broncos on one of the main two TVs at the bar not the one to the right. When asked we were told people are watching the other two games (one a Steelers fan) (and the bartender was a Ravens fan). This is broncos country. Only place in Greeley not playing it on the main TVs. Won’t come back for a game. Other than that food was good. Service Dine in Meal type Lunch Price per person $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 1

Jamie Candelarie

7 months ago

We came here and at first was extremely disappointed. We had to wait almost an hour for our pizza. Our waitress said because the kitchen had messed up our 1st one. We also ordered 2 sides of Alfredo sauce that was not prepared correctly and appeared curdled.... *** However, we brought the situation to the General Manager , Jeremy's attention, who in turn went above and beyond to fix the problems. He made us a new pizza himself that turned out perfect. He made us new Alfredo sauce, as well as did not charge us for our pizza entirely! He was extremely nice and wanted to make things right. A not so good experience that turned out great! Thanks Jeremy! Service: 5

Yolanda Marie E.

2 years ago

This was our first time ordering through Google take out for Old Chicago. The process felt very easy and quick. There was also a way to track where it was in the fulfillment process. I liked that part. Then, we got there to curbside pick up and waited almost 20 minutes. Big bummer. My favorite item is the salad because it has almonds but there were very few in mine. We also tried the Cauliflower pizza which was good. Pretzel bites and pepperoni pizza. The food was okay but was cold by the time we got home. We will not be partaking in the Google online order again for Old Chicago. Service Take out Meal type Brunch Price per person $50–100