Requested thin crust hand tossed, have of it is a bit under cooked dough not done taste and the other pieces crunchy from over cooked. There were only a few pieces of spinach on it, and it didn't look or taste the best pizza. I even had to add some shredded parmasan to help the taste. They may have had an off moment. I will try again, hopefully, for a better one
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 1
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 2
Bad experience: Started with the girl who answered the phone who was majorly lacking in customer service skills. Ordered two pizzas: one with pepperoni and black olives and one with pepperoni and jalapeños. When I picked them up, I noticed both had black olives. Told the girl at the front desk. No apology…didn’t seem to care one bit. She took the pizza to the back and returned about 5 min later. Again, no apology for my inconvenience. When I got home, I noticed they had the audacity to reuse the same pizza by removing (most) of the black olives and add the jalapeños!
So, Mr. Manager (if you exist)…what if I had a food allergy and that is why I asked for no olives on my pizza?? Anyone in the food industry should know what you did could kill someone!
This was the third (and unfortunately the final) time I order from your establishment. As a small business owner myself, customer experience is so important…one would only hope that you would take a serious look at your business. This makes me sad, as my family likes your pizza.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 2
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 3
I started working in Gunter a few months back and have ordered here several times now for lunch. I haven’t gotten anything that wasn’t good! And they have I think the best cauliflower crust pizza I’ve had. And the staff is super friendly!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Hot Ham & Cheese Sandwich
Small town and locally owned pizza place. We order twice a month and recently tried their cauliflower crust and OMG! I gotta say it's just a a good as the regular if not better. My cousin Vinny and The Phoebe are my favorite. Our order is normally ready in less than the 25 minutes (whoever is waiting 2 hours is doing something wrong) or maybe our small town was celebrating something that North Side Pie was sponsoring. 🤷♀️
I'm a big foodie and we recommend North Side pie. 😉 😜
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
I ordered online and was sent a message when it would be ready for pickup. I shared my food and everything was better than the last time.
Quick, Good, and local.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes
Small Cheesebread 10
Hosted a party with family and ordered some pies and sandwiches. My family doesn’t care for the dominoes or major chain pizza and truly enjoyed every bite. The staff and owners take the extra time to make it a great experience. If you want some mouth watering pizza with the best ingredients this is the place!
I've been twice now, and I'm very happy to have not only another option for lunch in town but also one that is so delicious.
I saw some other reviewers complain about the sauce. I disagree. The sauce is really tasty and definitely does not have that Spaghetti-o's taste that some cheap sauce has. Maybe they've improved their recipe. Plenty of cheese, great thin crust, good music inside, and of course a vintage arcade game machine for while you wait.
Have now ordered numerous pizzas of differing sizes and kinds, as well as a bulk order for a kids party, and their meatball subs. Their pizza is fantastic and their quality of sourcing is top-notch. Will definitely order from again. Great job and service.
The largest pizza they serve is 14” this is a medium/small at any other establishment but they charge $20 for it. The pizza tasted cheap as well. The only redeeming qualities of this shop is how much cheese they put on and the staff is friendly. Definitely better off getting a frozen pizza for 1/2 the cost and nearly twice the pizza.
The pizza is phenomenal! By far the best pizza in the county. However, everytime I've been there it takes about an hour and a half to 2 hours to actually get the pizza. If you place an online order make sure to place it 2 hours before you want to eat. But it is damn good pizza.
