My Daddy's Italian Bakery & Café Bakery in Surprise

Owner not registered
Reviews
#52 From 288 in Surprise
8.8
798 Review
Ambience
8.8/10
Food
8.8/10
Interior
8.8/10
Prices
8.8/10
Service
8.8/10
More details
Price & Cuisine
$$ Bakery
Establishment type
Bakery
Reviews
798 reviews
Rating
Sorting
Date
Date From - Date To
What a gem of a place! I had the freshest rainbow cookies and raspberry filled butter cookies ever! Absolutely delicious. I also had the margarita pizza. Also very good but the crust was a kind of soft, not firm as I expected. The cheese was wonderful and real baby tomatoes on top. Don't forget to try their fresh jumbo sized 5 cheese tortellini. It cooks in just a few minutes and is delicious!! I'll definitely be returning for more goodies! ❤️ Service Take out Meal type Dinner Price per person $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes Assorted Italian Cookies
avatar
Tracy Hagl
Source: google
10
A month ago
Went here for the first time and picked up all different sweet treats to make a dessert board. Everyone loved the board and all the desserts! The little lady helping was so nice and patient as I selected everything I needed. Will be back! Service Take out Meal type Other Price per person $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes Eclairs
Oh man what a treat. Must try! Problematically delicious. Best pizza in the valley, an authentic pizzaiolo. What a story, coming here from Italy and supporting his family. They are using wood fire and completely fresh ingredients. We got two pepperoni bambino’s (comes with a drink) and the My Daddy. Fresh bufala mozzarella, basil put on after being cooked and Italian seasoning. Great flavor, and a perfect sauce, not too sweet. I’ve had some of the more nationally acclaimed pizzas here in AZ and this is where I’ll be going for my next pizza! They are using wood fire and completely fresh ingredients. We got two pepperoni bambino’s (comes with a drink) and the My Daddy. Fresh bufala mozzarella, basil put on after being cooked and Italian seasoning. Great flavor, and a perfect sauce, not too sweet. We’ve had their frozen meals, subs, bread, desserts, pastries and now pizza. All amazing delicious. Update 10/21/23 The Margherita pizza and Diavolo were also amazing.
So affordable and a little slice of heaven. Always enjoy the tasty treats! Found out there's are gluten free options for pastries! Pictured in the box are the gluten free choices. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
avatar
Karen Dovidio
Source: google
10
5 months ago
This is quite a distance to drive for a bakery (30+ miles) but so worth it!!! The quality and quantity of items to choose from is amazing and there are many things that my husband and I haven't tried yet. So delicious!
Went and tried the brick oven pizzas! They are such a great tasting pizza! 😋 the people involved are so nice and great to talk to, and the man knows his stuff around a brick oven! Try them out if you're free on a Friday or Saturday night! (They make the pizza after they normally close 5 to 9)
Pizza was cooked so hot that the cheese didn't melt all the way but the crust and toppings burned. The pasties are not bad, but the clerk said to go to a different bakery for "really good" ones. It's better than fast food pizza and has authentic-ish Italian pastries. Service Take out Meal type Dinner Price per person $30–50 Food: 2 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 1
Great place to come grab some food, desserts and take home options. Indoor dining, options, wood fire pizza nights and lots of delicious good. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Come here about twice a week. Usually always great. Can't say enough about the lobster tails, cream horns, napoleons, and cookies. Donuts are awful, but you can get donuts and Danish anywhere. Special ordered a chocolate cake with whipped cream icing that was absolutely dry and tasteless, but they refunded my cake with no questions asked, which I greatly appreciated. The spumoni is great, and the last 2 interactions with staff have been great and friendly, a delightful change from the usual horrible attitude and rudeness, which I also appreciated. Will be back
avatar
K Costello
Source: google
8
A month ago
A bit chaotic the first time, but once you find, and read the posted sign as to where the next-in-line service ticket is. (It should be straight ahead instead of, off to the side) It's a go, and gets better. A great display of baked goods along with take home frozen Pizza and pasta. The frozen, take-home pastas Ziti, Ravioli entrees could use cooking instructions. Very nice, w great fresh baked bread! Service Take out Meal type Lunch Price per person $10–20 Food: 4 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes Bakery
become-owner-bg
Does this bellong to you?