Just moved to Huntington from Bay Ridge Brooklyn and by chance my wife and I walked by this place and saw menu items such as “shore road” and “67th street” (Places in bay ridge and dyker heights). What an amazing find!, if you are from Brooklyn or want authentic old school Italian products, treats and sandwiches this is THE place to go in Huntington. We are so happy we found this place that reminds us of Bay Ridge/Dyker and I was worried I would have to drive back to get a quality Italian sandwich, but this place definitely lives up to our standards. Rainbow cookies are A+++ like villabate alba. Amazing food. Thank you
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Stay away. I seen this place on a review somewhere, and decided to take a ride for lunch. As I entered the owner is behind the counter very unhappy to be there, or so it seems. He’s sweaty, sloppy, and unshaven. He asks what do you want to order as his bear hand wipes sweat off his forehead. He walks away and continues to wipe his sweaty face and beard, but I guess no biggie surely a place charging $20.00 dollars for sandwiches that considers themselves high end has high end procedures in place, and he will put gloves on. Little did I know he would make the same sandwich literally with the same hand that wiped his sweat off his face, and also later on scratched his nose while he made the food. Most of my horror came when he reached into the see thru fridge where he stored drenched peppers, and bare handed them with a side of covid, and sweat. I wouldn’t even bear hand wet ingredients in my own private home. What’s wrong with this guy?!?!?!
Not only are you getting the most disgusting unhygienic sandwich, but the owner sincerely has an aggressive attitude to his customers, and really needs to see someone for help. You can’t run a business like this!!! This is a health departments dream come true. If he’s doing this right in front of customers 4 feet away, I cannot imagine what happens in the back kitchen or after he’s done in the bathroom. I videoed the horror of this so the owner can’t deny I will post soon. Just change your ways mister angry man, put some gloves on, don’t touch your face, and when the cutting knife falls on the floor wash it off before reuse which I videoed, and most of all put a smile on your face for the suckers paying you that kind of money for a hero. When the customer leaves you can be angry all you want but fake it until you make buddy! Also parking is a nightmare!!! This place is gross, dirty, and the owner is a complete unaware slob to run this type of business. I’d venture to say he’s completely even unaware of how he behaves hygienically, and within his own personality which makes it even worse!
Food: 1
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 1
Mercado Cucina is a must-visit gem located in Huntington Long Island, originally from Dyker Heights section of Brooklyn. They serve one of the best handmade sandwiches that are made with love and homemade ingredients. Upon trying their sandwich, I was blown away by its deliciousness and couldn't finish it despite my best efforts.
Mercado Cucina prides itself on their attention to detail and quality, and it shows in their food. Their sandwiches are crafted with care, ensuring that each bite is packed with flavor. It's evident that they put a lot of effort and love into every dish they make.
If you're looking for a satisfying and delicious meal, Mercado Cucina is the place to go. Their sandwiches are a must-try, and their commitment to quality will keep you coming back for more.
Similar experience like Mister Luther except I parked in the rear I think in a residential parking lot because the road sidewalk parking was full. I’m not sure if he’s the owner but he certainly did make the sandwich with his bare hands I didn’t see him touch his face or anything but I’d say he’s not into hygiene or anything because he did touch each every cold cut and wet ingredients with his fingers. The cold cuts sit next to his slicer and I seen a couple flies landing on them during the process. The best part is while ringing me up for the sandwich I asked for napkins and he looked at me like I had 3 heads and in almost a temper said yea ok I got it! Like I was crazy or maybe I shouldn’t have asked cause he was gonna give them over shame on me. My sandwich was $17.00 or $18.00 even he just rounds up I believe, so I’m not sure if he charges the consumer tax correctly. I paid cash so I wonder if he just put that’s in his pocket, and cheats the tax man or does he actually deposit it. Very weird guy and store. The owner leaves nasty responses back but seems doesn’t deny fact of the no gloves or how he rounds up on the sales tax. Very gross. The way he responds to these post is same way he treats clients who eat his science project of sandwiches. Just for the record google ask for rating on service, atmosphere & food. Lots of luck 🍀
Food: 1
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 1
The first time I visited Mercato my expectations were admittedly pretty low. I was hangry and stopped in because it was convenient, ignoring the fact that the last place open in this spot served week old bagels. I brought home “The Capo” and my first impression was that it was enough for 2 meals… it was so good that it wound up being 2 bites. I’ve visited at least another dozen times since and each time I’m just as impressed as the first. The sandwiches are generous in size and made with truly top shelf ingredients. I’ve lived in Huntington my whole life and can guarantee no one is putting out a product like this. My girlfriend and I both recently attended a cheese making class hosted by Chef David. He taught the basic principles of fresh cheese and how to incorporate them into home cooked dishes. We’ve both been cooking since we were kids yet learned so much from Chef David at class. The Chef, and his better half Deb, are truly committed to their shop and making it feel like home for their customers - just don’t ask him for whole wheat bread, subways down the road. I’m so thankful to have Mercato so close by. Don’t miss it!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
My wife wouldn’t allow me to cook
For my 50th and we needed quality food for my family! This place utilizes the best ingredients and is all hand crafted by an amazing chef (David) The food was truly delicious and Dave even took into account my nieces allergies making me feel at ease at the party. The service was impeccable and I will be using this place solely for all
Of my catering needs going forward. Thank you again Dave! Ps his family does amazing work for those with special needs! Check out the Clark Gilles center next door!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
The 67th Street
My family and i did a private cooking lesson with david to celebrate my daughter’s birthday. David taught us to make his master sauce, a shrimp dish and fresh mozzarella. He used quality ingredients and educated us on how to find the best ingredients to use at home. Overall a really fun experience that i would highly recommend. Thanks so much david!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Better than 5 stars! Reminds me of the deli sandwiches of Bensonhurst Brooklyn. The names of the sandwiches reflect that area of Brooklyn and I haven't had one since I moved out of there in the late 90s. Well not anymore! This place will definitely be on my places to regularly visit.
The sandwiches may seem a bit on the expensive side at first glance but do not be deterred. They are worth every penny and then some. The ingredients are top notch and the bread, the bread alone is worth the trip to visit the shop. I haven't had bread like this in a very long time. A often forgotten piece of the sandwich puzzle but great bread will make a great sandwich even better.
We had the capo and 18th ave today and I am definitely craving the godmother and rocco for the next visit. I finished the entire sandwich and didn't feel bloated, just a happy full. No acid reflux, no gassy burps, just a calm and happy satiated stomach.
I am not a big coffee drinker (figure a random one once a month) but the dyker heights and cinque have changed my mind. I can drink these two everyday.
I can't find anything displeasing about Mercato Cucina. The parking can be a little scarce (although there is a resident permit parking lot across the street which is almost always empty.)
Buy any one of their sandwiches which spikes your interest, drink a coffee while the sandwich is being made, take home said sandwich and enjoy with an adult beverage of your choice then live happily ever after!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
As an industry person there is no better feeling than "I can't wait to make my way through the menu"
Mercato Cucina embodies that sentiment with high quality ingredients that are executed perfectly and professionally by skilled individuals. The heart and integrity of the care put into a simple sandwich can be tasted in every bite. You can tell Chef David put alot of thought into the design and layout of both the menu and space which is simple, quaint and meaningful yet inviting. Simple food done right. Doesent get any better and I look foward to coming here when in the area.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
I’ve been driving by this place frequently and have always wanted to stop in. My wife and her friend went for lunch the other day and raved about it, so we tried it for breakfast. Man. This place is fantastic; they definitely use high quality ingredients. Place is cool and clean, staff friendly and welcoming. Going back, for sure!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Breakfast
Price per person
$1–10
