Mario's Pizzeria Pizzeria in Melville

Name: Mario's Pizzeria
Address: 1-17 Schwab Rd, Melville, United States
Telephone: 16313857000
Rating: 4.0

Owner not registered

Mario's Pizzeria

Reviews

#30 From 59 in Melville

266 Review

Ambience

8/10

Food

8/10

Interior

8/10

Prices

8/10

Service

8/10

More details

Price & Cuisine

$$ Pizza, Italian , Salads

Establishment type

Pizzeria

Features

Information

+16313857000

1-17 Schwab Rd, Melville, United States

Get direction

Website Mario's Pizzeria

About

This pizzeria and Walt Whitman Birthplace can be both really attractive for tourists. At Mario's Pizzeria, you will be offered Italian cuisine. That's a nice idea to order perfectly cooked Caesar salads, pies and Pepperoni. Food delivery is a big plus of this place. A number of visitors have noticed that the staff is energetic at this spot. People mention that the service is fast here. This pizzeria provides meals at good prices. Most of the time, the spectacular atmosphere is to be found here. Google users like Mario's Pizzeria: it was granted 4.2 stars.

Rating

Excellent

146

Very Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

Sorting

Newest

Oldest

Ascending rating

Descending rating

Date

Date From - Date To

Michael

Source:

3 weeks ago

Stop by here for lunch on occasion and just constantly disappointed. Why is the food so much worse than the other sister Mario's locations? Core marinara sauce tastes straight from a can.... Pizza is either undercooked or scalding hot - never in the middle.... Knots are soggy. Why do I come here, you ask? Mainly because it's a lot less busy than the other spots in the area like Victors - which is great when I'm in a rush. The dining room is clean and the workers are friendly. As a big fan of the other locations, someone needs to look into why it's so different. Food: 2 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 4

Paul Sloboda

A week ago

The staff forgot about my dine in order. Waited 10 minutes for two slices. When they finally brought me the slices they were blackened and inedible. Yup - worst service ever. Offered me new slices if I wanted to wait for another ten minutes - no thanks. Just go to another pizzeria. Mario’s continually disappoints. Service Dine in

Marie Philemond

6 months ago

Pizza and Salad was great! Service was also on point! Will definitely be back again. Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Rich P

A month ago

Monday night. Needed something good to counter a tough day. Mario’s comes through. As always. Delicious. Thank you. Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Libby Matamoros

2 months ago

Called and placed order for delivery at 5:40pm was never told delivery would take an hour. Sat around waiting and watched my kids eat their food thinking mine and my husbands food would be at our house shortly but were we wrong. Called back at 6:30pm and they told me driver should be at your door in 10 mins a half hour went by when he finally showed up at 7:00pm. We sat down and our food was ice cold. Very disappointed in Mario’s. Service Delivery Meal type Dinner Price per person $30–50 Food: 1 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Harrison Morales

Roberto is a very nice person/worker he is very helpful with my order he is very nice person and Mario’s food and service very nice and food very excellent this pizzeria deserves medal for there nice service pizza 10 out 10 and employees are very nice I have been to this Mario’s pizzeria location in Melville since 2004 for 20 years try food very excellent sandwiches and burgers and wraps are very nice. Service Dine in Meal type Lunch Price per person $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes Italian

fawn

Used to love this place until they repeatedly gave me burnt pizza. You really saw this and thought “Perfect! Let’s serve this” that’s crazy. Service Take out Price per person $20–30 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

Jane Im

4 months ago

This place has the most delicious seafood pasta!! Mario's seafood special was incredibly delicious!! Definitely 5 stars!!! They make homemade authentic Italian food! Highly recommended you won't be disappointed. Meal type Dinner Price per person $100+ Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

George Panagopoulos at Douglas Elliman Realestate

A year ago

First time at Mario’s of Huntington, I have been to many of the other locations. I ordered a regular slice and grandma it was good but I expected it to be better. To be fair it was 3pm so not the best time to get a fresh slice. The pizza is never the same when you re-heat it. Overall good experience and the service was solid.

Alexis Valinchus

7 months ago

This place used to be good. Went here today with my boyfriend and they’ve become very disorganized. Number one, we ordered pizza “to stay” and got it in a to go box. Next the pizza was barely even warm even though it came out of the oven. The cheese wasn’t even melting like it would on a normal hot slice of pizza. Very doughy and undercooked. Think the only good thing was the soda. Never coming back here!