Goldy's Gems Restaurant,Bar in Bay Shore

Name: Goldy's Gems
Address: 5 Third Ave, Bay Shore, United States
Telephone: 16316659596
Rating: 4.8

Owner not registered

Goldy's Gems

Reviews

#4 From 97 in Bay Shore

9.7

38 Review

Ambience

9.7/10

Food

9.7/10

Interior

9.7/10

Prices

9.7/10

Service

9.7/10

More details

Price & Cuisine

$ International

Establishment type

Restaurant, Bar

Features

Wheelchair Accessible

Information

5 Third Ave, Bay Shore, United States

Get direction

Website Goldy's Gems

About

After you have seen Bay Shore Historical Society, come to this bar. Most guests of Goldy's Gems note that good chicken and perfectly cooked chicken sandwiches are served here. The gracious staff works hard, stays positive and makes this place wonderful. There is pleasant atmosphere at this place, as clients find it. This spot scored 4.8 in the Google rating system.

Rating

Excellent

Very Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

Sorting

Newest

Oldest

Ascending rating

Descending rating

Date

Date From - Date To

Samantha

Source:

A month ago

I recently had a Birds and Bubble Brunch Buffet here for a surprise party and I was extremely happy with my event. The staff, Tiffany and Michelle, were both amazing. Goldy’s Gems is a perfect spot for a party and the guests were all talking about how great of a place it was. The service was amazing and the two employees working the party were on top of everything. The price was reasonable per person and the brunch food was very good. We had no complaints and would definitely have another party here in the future! Price per person $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 2

Crissie Scibilia

A year ago

I had my daughter's bridal shower here this past weekend and it was AMAZING!! Melissa was on point from start to finish, made sure the food was flowing throughout the party. Michelle, our bartender, was so attentive to me & my guests, drinks were perfect, she's the ultimate mixologist. The food was delicious too! Everyone raved about the duck tacos!!! Everything was phenomenal!

Ron Hughes

Recently held a surprise 60th birthday party for my mother in-law and honestly had a great experience. I’ve been a regular patron of Goldy’s for since their rebirth; however, recently I inquired about their party services. The process was simple. Even doing homework, price-wise they were competitive with the going rate per person. The staff was tremendous in making the event a hit! They were accommodating, attentive - overall made the experience a pleasure! Again, I would highly recommend and will continue to frequent Goldy’s as a regular patron! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Mitchel Djurik

9 months ago

Melissa was very helpful and helped us pick this place for my wife's surprise 30th birthday party. We had the best party ! We had about 65 people and had more than enough space. The whole staff was amazing, and the food was excellent. Especially the chicken sliders and chickpea fries we're a big hit! Definitely would recommend this place for a private event or a night out filled with dancing and drinks.

Melissa Guijarro

I recently hosted my son’s first birthday here and Goldy’s did an amazing job! The entire process from planning to the day of was seamless. Melissa was on point, on top of everything, and very accommodating. Our server and bartender the day of were great and so nice. Anything we asked for or needed they delivered. The food was soooo good. We got so many compliments from our guests! If you’re considering hosting your next event here, or even just stopping in one night for a drink & some food, I promise you will not regret it. Thank you so much Goldy’s Gems for such a great experience!!!

Amanda Stashin

4 months ago

Just had my bridal shower here this weekend and it was AMAZING. It was everything I could've imagined for myself. The venue was perfect. It was a great space, easy to mingle, and there was plenty of seating. It was exactly the vibe I was looking for. Melissa was great to work with and the staff on that day were all attentive and helpful. Would absolutely have an event here again.

jonathan Afanador

Goldy’s!! Everything about this spot was absolutely perfect. The hospitality, the vibe, the staff. All outstanding. Melissa and Tiffany were the absolute best in making sure our engagement party was the best that it could be. If you’re thinking about Goldy’s to visit or have your party hosted, it’s a must. I was sold on having Goldy’s be my venue the second I walked in. Nothing but great things about this place.

Carlven Joseph

5 months ago

Simply a great bar/venue. I recently hosted my 30th birthday celebration here, and everyone had a blast! The staff is amazing and very professional. Melissa was helpful with getting everything assituated. Johnny and Tiffany especially, provided superb service throughout the whole night and it was greatly appreciated. Johnny was amazing with his bartending skills. Tiffany was superb and attentive throughout, keeping things running smoothly while always making you feel comfortable with any questions or concerns you may have. I couldn't have asked for a better host and bartender, so thank you again Johnny and Tiffany! If you're looking for a cozy, casual bar with great food, music, drinks, and a good time, be sure to stop at Goldy's Gems. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes Chicken Sandwich

Megan Ricca

We had our engagement party here and it was amazing!!!! The space is great they have a restaurant buy our deals for parties! We got so many compliments on the space it’s so perfect for a party where you want to be more social rather than a sit down !!!! The food is amazing!!! We had the option to choose four options, we choose the bavarian pretzels, chic-pea fries, chicken sliders and cheeseburger sliders…..everything was so good!!! Our guests were raving about the food!!! We were able to bring our own dessert and they supplied a table which was great! This place is a 1000000/10!!!! So great! What a hidden gem ☺️

Scott Butler

7 months ago

About a year ago my partner and I walked into Goldy’s Gems. We were greeted with sincerity and had several drinks and apps. It was then that we wanted to have our joint birthday party which evolved into our engagement party here. We were not let down in the least!!! The party was a hit thanks to Melissa, Michelle, and Tiffany. My step mom from out of town said that she never had an empty glass. To me, that is above and beyond service and consideration. The DJ they offer knew exactly what to play and we let him do his thing. We have such gratitude for it being a beautiful celebration and we will always remember! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5