I've ordered lunch here a number of times. The sandwiches are genuinely pretty decent. The service has gone down hill a lot. This time I picked up my order and was heckled by the staff for asking to put my four subs into a bag. Upon checking out the staff began mocking and insulting me like they were in elementary school. I was speechless by their immaturity and overall behavior toward their customers. My recommendation is to avoid this establishment completely. I will not be returning.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 3
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 1
We’ve been meaning to try this place for a few years now. Specially, for boat days. We finally ordered from here today on Seamless because it’s the quickest and easiest with small children. It was ready very quickly thankfully, but when I arrived, I wanted to double check the order before taking it and someone working there. Told the other guy working there: Take care of “the customers first” bc I’m a Seamless order. So be clear I’m not a Seamless driver (not that there’s anything wrong with that) but I had ordered almost $70 worth of 5 half sandwiches to be clear and AM 100% a paying customer just as a seamless order would be..good food but sad that an online orders extra moneys no good there.
Price per person
$50–100
Food: 5
Service: 1
We ordered trays of food for a family reunion. We had 24 people and ordered the deal for 20-24 people. $300. We didn't think it looked like enough when we picked it up but it ended up being exactly the amount of food we needed. Even some leftovers! (They know what they're doing when it comes to catered food.) Everything was EXCELLENT! We ordered the eggplant parm, tortellini alfredo, rigatoni, and chicken francese. Raves all around! Came with delicious Italian bread and salad, plus antipasto. We will definitely order again. Thank you to Fusciello's!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Eggplant Parm
Rude staff with decent food. Plenty of selection on drinks and food options. Sandwiches and sides were decent, nothing special, but staff was miserable and rude. The feeling like you’re bothering them by coming in. Take your order and fail to acknowledge you, talk amongst each other while you’re speaking to them and mumble when speaking to customers. Pathetic. Definitely will not be returning.
I am new to the area so my husband and I decided to try this deli. Both times no one said hello (1st time thought it was a fluke b/c all teenagers were behind the counter on a Sunday) AND masks were either not worn or worn properly. At the deli my husband asked for some meats and cheeses to be sliced very thin but to please put paper between the slices (so they keep their original form and are easy to grab. There is also a medical reason for the easy grab which should not ever have to be explained). They refused to put the paper stating it costs too much!!! It’s a deli! An expensive deli at that! I still have a pound of cheese no one can pull a single slice from! When my husband asked if the capicola was cured, they said yes! Instead we received, basically, bologna. At less than 1/2 pound it was $8.64. Both times Honey ham and Honey Turkey spoiled within two days and bread hard as a rock within one day.
I will absolutely go somewhere else!
I usually pick up sandwiches and deli items for the weekend boat days. Today was the first time I took home some cooked items such as the stuffed bread and stuffed artichokes and both were amazing.
roomy place good selection nice balance of prepared foods meat and poultry and baked goods...
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Ordered a whole Peter Luger, disappointed in the roast beef. Lots of fat, had to throw out much of the roast beef. Bread and cheese was good.
I’ve ordered this sandwich many times in the past, first one that was this disappointing
7/15 update. Stopped by and was politely given a fresh sandwich for free. Very happy with the response. Sandwich was great
Excellent deli with lots of specialty sandwiches. Highly recommend.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Best sub sandwiches you can get in town, as far as I'm concerned - and I've tried 'em all...even that "other" popular butcher. They weigh the meat out for your sub (I've never seen this anywhere else), so you know your sandwiches are gonna be consistent. Their Italian bread is also excellent; I don't mind paying a few extra bucks for a good loaf of Italian. It's even warm, sometimes! I also suggest walking around the store, because they have some items you'd be surprised to find - I found HOT cherry peppers on the shelf when I couldn't find them anywhere else. I strongly suggest giving Fusciello's a try.
