Eileen's Colossal Cookies Cafe in Sioux Falls
Owner not registered
More details
Price & Cuisine
$$$
International
Establishment type
Cafe
Reviews
94
reviews
Sorting
Date
Date From - Date To
Source:
2
2 months ago
Two days before I order cookies I called and got prices of $3 per cookie, so one day later I order 2 dozen four inch decorated cookies over the phone. The price stated over the phone to me was $3 each. The store called back a few minutes later and told me the price she stated to me was the wrong and the price was $1 more per cookie. I agreed to the price cause I was done dealing with ordering cookies. When I went in to pick up the cookies the menu sign hanging right next to the cash register said 4 inch decorated cookies were $3 each, I told the the lady what I got charged and then showed her that the menu sign says $3 a piece. The lady helping me went to the register and came back and said the price is wrong on the menu sign. How can your menu sign say one thing and then charge more? Had I not already paid for them weeks ago and not having any other options for a Christmas gift, I took the cookies and left. So the moral of the story is don’t believe the prices on the menu. I will not the going back!
Service
Take out
Price per person
$100+
Food: 2
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 2
Source:
10
9 months ago
The BEST cookies EVER! Lemony vanilla cookie dough with super creamy icing that melts in your mouth. The shop is cute and always clean. The staff are always friendly and it’s nice to see them all baking the cookies from scratch in the open kitchen. Prices are great for the quality. Highly recommend for special occasions or just treating yourself 😁👍
Source:
8
5 months ago
This was my first visit. The store had a variety of cookies. There were pre-bagged cookies and glass display cases with individual cookies. There were also signs displaying prices for large party-sized cookies. My friend and I both chose chocolate mint from the display case.
The cookie was chewy and dark like a brownie. I liked it very much.
The icing was so soft, I had a difficult time breaking a piece of the cookie off. I broke the cookie off from underneath so I wouldn't have icing all over my hands.
The green colored icing screamed, "Mint," but I would have appreciated more mint flavoring. I put the cookie in the refrigerator to firm the icing up. The cold seemed to detract from the taste of the cookie and frosting, but both were still good. My husband thought it was good, and when I visited my friend that night, she didn't have much of her cookie left. 😊
Source:
10
2 years ago
Delicious cookies only $2 each! We had the peanut butter, lemon butter cream, and white chocolate macadamia. The macadamia was my favorite.
Source:
10
2 weeks ago
Enjoy the sweet cookies every time I stop and price is great. They never disappoint me
Service
Take out
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Sugar Cookie with Unicorn Design
Source:
10
5 years ago
In town from Minnesota and saw this place on my Maps and had to try them out. I'm a freak for lemon cookies and have just found my favorite lemon cookie ever! Best cookies I've had hands down. I would drive another 200 miles just to have these cookies in my life. Thank Eileen's Cookies!!
Source:
10
A year ago
A friend of mine recommended going to Eileen's as she stops by almost every time she is in town for a bag or a dozen to share with others.
From the time I stepped in the door I felt welcome. Great selection and the prices are excellent for the value!
Make sure to stop by and experience these classic, yummy cookies!!!
Source:
10
3 months ago
Best cookies I've ever had!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Source:
2
10 months ago
Every cookie I've ever tried has been undercooked to the point that it's mushy and disgusting. Definitely avoid this place unless you want a heaping dose of food poisoning and disappointment.
Source:
10
2 years ago
Their monster cookies are some of the best I've ever had. Have always had great customer service. We recently ordered a cookie cake through Sky Zone for a birthday party and they use Eileen's. Turned out fantastic!
Does this bellong to you?