Catalina's Bake Shop Bakery in Dix Hills
Owner not registered
More details
Price & Cuisine
$$
Bakery
Establishment type
Bakery
Reviews
10
reviews
Sorting
Date
Date From - Date To
Source:
10
2 weeks ago
We’ve experimented with many different bake shops and literally nothing has come close to the goodness at Catalina’s bake shop. It’s a little further for us than all the other bake shops near us, but it’s worth the trip every single time. We originally discovered this place when I needed a cake for my daughter’s birthday which came out absolutely beautiful and was the best tasting cake we have ever. Now it’s also our spot for occasional treats. You can tell the owner/baker is extremely passionate about what they do and it’s what makes everything so good!
Meal type
Other
Source:
10
A month ago
I ordered a heart shaped chocolate cake with chocolate ganache filling for my friends 21st birthday and I couldn’t be happier. It came out exactly how I wanted it and they were so patient with all my questions. It was an easy process from beginning to end and the price was so worth it! The cake was delicious and my friend absolutely loved it! I would definitely order from here again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Source:
10
2 months ago
Amazing experience here! Ordered a cake last minute for our engagement photos… Wanted something vintagey and sweet. They went above and beyond and it looked PERFECT and tasted just as good! The staff were SO nice and accommodating. The shop is beautiful and clean. I will 100% be back for future events. Honest people that do great work. I HIGHLY recommend them!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$50–100
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Wedding Cake
Source:
10
3 months ago
I ordered a customized strawberry shortcake Super Mario cake for my son’s birthday as a first time customer just after searching for a bakery online. An AMAZING custom cake was created. Catalina, did exactly what I wanted from the picture I provided and it was more affordable than other highly rated bakeries. I paid $210 with a 20% deposit ($42.00). This cake was so pretty and most importantly DELICIOUS/FRESH. Catalina, was really sweet & did an amazing job. I definitely will be coming back. Thanks Catalina.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Other
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Source:
10
3 months ago
Her recipes for her signature 6 inch cakes are delicious, the cake and frosting are both so very light & fluffy , unlike so many other traditional cakes elsewhere. So far we have had my fave - the Black & White, plus the Funfetti and Canolli cake. Also she has plenty of other yummy baked goods , and a very friendly staff.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Source:
10
4 months ago
Thx so much for making my son's birthday cake to yummy and the design I wanted. It was perfect for our little prince. Will definitely buy from you again. Keep up the good work!
Source:
10
5 months ago
Phenomenal cake! We ordered a vanilla cake with fresh fruit and pastry cream filling and cream cheese frosting. It was incredible. The cake was moist with a perfect texture, berries were fresh, and nothing was "too sweet." Catalina worked with me for the colors and design, and they delivered the most beautiful cake I've ever had the pleasure to pay for. My guests loved it, and we are looking forward to ordering from this bakery for all of our future occasions.
Source:
10
5 months ago
We tried a sample of Catalina’s cake at a bridal expo and we knew immediately we needed her for our wedding. We had an amazing cake tasting with 3 flavors and discussed what we were looking for. The cost was then deducted from the total cost of the cake. Our final cake was absolutely STUNNING. She executed our vision perfectly and we couldn’t have asked for better.
Source:
10
8 months ago
This bake shop was recommended to me by the Garden City Hotel and I have used them for my daughter’s engagement party and Bridal Shower. All I can say is Wow. We gave them a picture of a cake my daughter liked and she made exactly what the picture looked like. Not only that, but the cake was delicious. Absolutely fantastic place!
Source:
10
11 months ago
2nd experience-: Visited the bakery in person to pick up my son’s half birthday cake (Mickey mouse, pic attached ).
It’s a beautiful😻 little pasty shop. Absolutely spic and span👌🏻 Josette is most friendly and courteous 👏🏻 And Catalina is so talented 😽. Amazing custom cakes ; wedding cakes etc . Definitely visiting again.
Highly recommend 👍🏻
1st experience-: Fantastic customer experience. They’re extremely customer centric. And highly professional. Definitely considering them in future as well. HIGHLY RECOMMEND ❤️👍🏻
Does this bellong to you?