The Italian Hoagie is my favorite. I love everything about this place from the old school vibe / decor to the awesome hoagies. Casella’s is one of my first stops when I get into Scottsdale. Make sure to bring cash because they are “Cash Only.”
Stopped by for a carry out lunch out today as I was looking forward to tying this local family owned joint.
The staff was friendly and helpful on my two selections.
I did the Pepper and Cheese and wifey did their Ham and Cheese. I will say their bread is amazing and soft and the sauce used for the P & C was sweet and savory. Loved it!
I had a bite of the Ham and Cheese and it was great. My P & C was good but I think if there was a toasted bread option, that would've been great. Since the heat of the sandwich and given it was rolled up in Aluminum Foil, it made the bread a little squishy.
If I go back, I feel either eat a hot sandwich there or stick with the Cold sandwiches.
Plenty of strip mall parking and CASH ONLY!!!
Absolutely incredible experience! I did go when Larry Fitzgerald covered everyone's meal 😆 The staff was amazing and enthusiastic, Not to mention how energetic and happy Joe was😍😆😁 Even the people in line were great. I got there early but they were still running out of the stuff that people recommended (chicken salad sandwich, desserts, and 🤔 well almost everything I asked for lol) I love the staff I asked a lady to surprise me especially because I am new. She did and WOWZA 😍 the meatball is awesome which btw I'm not a fan of meatball. I can't wait to go back to try so many things 😆😆😆
