Brooklyn Square Pizza Pizzeria in Toms River

Name: Brooklyn Square Pizza
Address: 1898 Hinds Rd, Toms River, United States
Telephone: 17327696333
Rating: 4.1

Owner not registered

Brooklyn Square Pizza

Reviews

#122 From 257 in Toms River

8.2

379 Review

Ambience

8.2/10

Food

8.2/10

Interior

8.2/10

Prices

8.2/10

Service

8.2/10

More details

Price & Cuisine

$$ Pizza, Italian

Establishment type

Pizzeria

Features

Wheelchair Accessible

Information

1898 Hinds Rd, Toms River, United States

Get direction

Website Brooklyn Square Pizza

About

Search through the Italian menu. Food delivery is an important benefit of this pizzeria. You can always try tasty Pepperoni, salads and buffalo chicken at Brooklyn Square Pizza. Most users mention that the staff is cute. The enjoyable atmosphere makes a positive impression on reviewers. As for the Google rating, this place got 4.2.

Rating

Excellent

241

Very Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

Sorting

Newest

Oldest

Ascending rating

Descending rating

Date

Date From - Date To

Kevin Kastner

Source:

2 months ago

I ordered a pizza yesterday and when it arrived half the pizza was burnt. I spoke to a “supervisor” who told me he would take my number down and call me later because they were busy. I replied that wasn’t good enough & then he said that i could get a 10$ credit off of a 30$ pizza. He explained he cannnot guarantee his work when they get busy. After about an hour he told me he would issue me a refund. I called back today to ask when i would receive my refund & he replied what is your name as if he had no idea we spoke. Followed with yes call in again & get a 10$ credit. This is the pizza that was sent to me. Service Delivery Meal type Dinner Price per person $30–50 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

Gail Sapone

A month ago

Pizza was delicious. The sauce, Cheese and crust were all very tasty. I got the honey pepperoni. I thought the combo sounded weird but it was delicious! My sister got the plain and she thought the same. It was my first time there but I’ll be back. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 3

Boat House

3 months ago

The square pie is amazing. Lots of flavor. Good texture. Great outside crust. I can’t wait to try the circle sesame pie next ! Delicious !!! Best Vodka Chicken Parm I’ve ever had. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Daniel

11 months ago

Solid pizza joint in a prime location plenty of parking. Lots of options for slices (which is what I had) but the pie/regular menu was packed as well. Friendly guys behind the counter and fast service I tried the pepperoni, cheese, and grandma slice. All were flavorful and good (wish there was a bit more sauce on the grandma but I like it saucy). Prices are great compared to other places around here Service Take out Meal type Dinner Price per person $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4

Vincent Scardilli

I ordered online and accidentally sent the order to the Jackson store. The manager came out and fixed the problem and made the order and didn’t charge me any extra. Their food is consistently great quality and their pizza is the best Sicilian style in the area. Great local business. Service Take out Meal type Lunch Price per person $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

John O’Neill

Ordered a large plain pizza to go. When I received the pie I said "that was quick". After eating one slice I could tell it was undercooked, I reheated the rest of the pie. Two hours later I began to feel ill, twelve hours later the runs, two days later still running. I have had food poisoning before and that is definitely what I got from eating one slice. I will, and would recommend to all, stay away from this place. Food: 1

Tina Babe

6 months ago

I don't know what happened to this place. Every piece of roast beef on my Brooklyn roast beef sandwich with Motor oil we're cut into pieces and taste like processed meat. I am very disappointed. John's Deli from Brooklyn, YOU ARE NOT!! You are just a wannabe copycat. Shame on you!! Service Take out Meal type Lunch Price per person $20–30 Food: 1

Joseph Lanzarotta

2 years ago

Really good pizza here the upside down was great had great sauce high quality cheese and the dough was crunchy on the outside and fluffy in the inside it was great and the regular slice was good and loved the sesame seed crust will definitely have it again!!

Jackie Nowak

5 years ago

First time here tonight, my husband and I have been searching for the best pizza in Tom's River area. We may have found it tonight at this tiny pizzeria. We wanted to dine in but the place has limited seating. We looked over the pizza and the menu and decided to try a slice of their square pizza that had pepperoni on it. We took it to our car because there was no place to sit for dinner. Was very good, crust was thick and crunchy, the sauce was very good sweet and acidic too. We were still hungry so we decided to go back in, this time there were three tables that were available so we sat down. We decided to try the pizza that was round called the Sophia. This pizza had fresh tomato's, garlic and regular mozzarella on it. (you could order it with smoked mozzarella) I really liked the pizza but my spouse didn't care for the mozzarella he said it was too thick and very chewy. I love cheese so I really enjoyed it. The two pizzas we tried had sesame seeds on them. They have a large menu, so they sell meals too and the plates looked like large portions. I just wish the place was bigger. Met the owners they were very nice and so was our waitress.

Amanda Me

2 weeks ago

Delicious square pizza, chicken vodka parm dinner and meatball parm sub. Best pizza in area. I've tried most.. It's definitely a must try if you're still looking for good pizza in Toms River.. Service Take out Meal type Lunch Price per person $50–100 Food: 4 Service: 5 Recommended dishes Chicken Grippo