Big Pauly's Wood Fired PIZZA Pizzeria in Plainfield

Name: Big Pauly's Wood Fired PIZZA
Address: 15412 South Rt. 59, Plainfield, United States
Telephone: 18152676155
Rating: 4.5

Owner not registered

Big Pauly's Wood Fired PIZZA

Reviews

#19 From 154 in Plainfield

9.1

447 Review

Ambience

9.1/10

Food

9.1/10

Interior

9.1/10

Prices

9.1/10

Service

9.1/10

More details

Price & Cuisine

$$ Italian , Pizza

Establishment type

Pizzeria

Information

+18152676155

15412 South Rt. 59, Plainfield, United States

Get direction

Website Big Pauly's Wood Fired PIZZA

About

The Italian cuisine is good at this pizzeria. Have a nice time here and share tasty sausage pizza, garlic knots and beef sandwiches with your friends. Many people come to taste good cannolis, tiramisu and ice cream. You will be offered delicious margaritas, craft beer or wine. At Big Pauly's Wood Fired PIZZA, you can get a takeaway. The staff is cheerful that's what makes this place so good. Nice service is something that guests highlight in their comments. Prices are low for the quality you receive. There is a pleasant atmosphere and cute decor at this spot. This pizzeria is rated on Google 4.6 by its clients.

Rating

Excellent

349

Very Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

Sorting

Newest

Oldest

Ascending rating

Descending rating

Date

Date From - Date To

Megan Leleniewski

Source:

5 months ago

Fantastic pizza!! We all got our own smaller pizzas so we could try a bunch, did not disappoint. Service was great, and if it wasn't chilly out, I'd love to eat outside. Definitely will be coming back and recommending to others! Service Dine in Meal type Lunch Price per person $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes Garlic Knots

Jeanine

7 months ago

What a gem to find. The staff is really helpful and friendly, which speaks volumes in todays industry standards. The garlic knots were recommended to us, and they are SO delicious & sauce tasted homemade. The pizza we chose had mushrooms, onion, green pepper and sausage and it was cooked to perfection. What I liked about the pizza the most is that it wasn't too heavy. I left the restaurant feeling good, not weighed down and bloated. We will most certainly be back. Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Price per person $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes St Rocco

Megan Bruno

A month ago

Picked up the chopped salad for the first time. $17 and got maybe 1.5 cherry tomatoes . The lack of ingredients for that price was insane. I came home and added my own ingredients to make it more than a bowl of lettuce. Very disappointing.

Les O'Connor Jr

11 months ago

Very nice and reasonably priced pizza place! Wife/I did a small build-your-own pizza to get our favorite toppings, but they also have several different specialty pizzas that cover a variety of tastes. There is a small selection of beers/wine available, but there's no bar, so no mixed drinks/cocktails. The restaurant was very clean, the wait staff was exceptionally friendly & attentive, and the owner also introduced himself and engaged in conversation with us, explaining the history of the family restaurant. Enjoyed the pizza and will go back in the near future to try some other menu items. Somewhat of a small space, not a lot of seating, so be careful about the time you choose (weekend evenings may get crowded quickly), but overall, I would definitely recommend it. Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Price per person $20–30 Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Jenna Llewellyn

2 months ago

We have done carry out twice now and both times have been super happy! Service is always friendly, pizzas are always made super fresh out of the oven as I walk in the door, and they're delicious! We had a large group pizza night from Big Pauly's and everyone was begging to know where we got the delicious food from! Can't recommend enough. Service Take out Meal type Dinner Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes St Rocco

Michael Murphy

We came for the 1st time. The menu was almost too good to choose one. We went for the Great White. AMAZING. we also had the garlic knots. KILLER GOOD!! The corn was a unique twist and delicious. The staff was amazing. You need to get in here in get their food in your face!!! You will not be disappointed. Already planing the next trip Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Gloria “Gigi” Mendez

9 months ago

We totally enjoyed our food and service. We order the garlic knots. OMG, they were the best garlic knots we ever had! Mac and cheese was cooked perfectly, adding some alfredo sauce and took it to another level. The Butchers pizza was a tad salty, but it was full of flavor and the sauce was great. The cinque formaggio was delicious 😋 . Be prepared to spend some $$, but it is worth it. Come and try this place, at least just for the garlic knots! Service Dine in Meal type Lunch Price per person $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Stephanie S.

8 months ago

A friend recommended this place to me last year and since then my husband and I have been here about 5 times. The pizza is amazing and we always get the Buffalo wings as an appetizer. The Buffalo wings are super spicy so be aware of that. I do wish you got more than 6 wings for the price but it’s a small business so I’m willing to overlook that. We usually get the 5 cheese pizza and we’ve gotten the Margarita before. Both are awesome. Wood fired, chewy crust but still crispy. It’s hard now for date night because we never want to go anywhere else but Big Paulys since we know for sure we will get a great meal. 😂 Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Price per person $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes Jumbo Roasted Wings

Mike Kreusch

3 months ago

I tried to go to CosMc’s but it’s a three hour drive thru line So I Google “pizza” One review of this place sez “best ever, no kidding” 100% true fact 1) the place is large bright and spotless clean 2) the proprietor is a genuine nicest guy in the world 3) the food is apex, honestly, it cannot be improved 4) price point = amazing value Describe the pizza 700F oven doughy crispy crust and underside Not cracker thin closer to NY style Really good sauce and generous cheese coverage I got soppressata - classy that they have it Garlic knot sliders are last meal worthy I typically don’t dessert Here I will for sure Service Dine in Meal type Lunch Price per person $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes The Butcher Pizza

John Miller

6 years ago

So the pizza is good above all. If you like a more "gourmet" style pizza, you'll really love Big Pauly's. I have 3 thoughts/suggestions. 1- The service was slow. I also understand it's a Friday night and we got the last dine in table and it's wood fired pizza. It's going to take awhile. 2- there was some confusion on our order and we got a pizza not the way we ordered it. It's the first week of being open, I understand that things still have to be worked out, but our server never really apologised or took ownership of the mistake. It sounded like it was our fault the pizza was ordered wrong. I remember clearly ordering it a different way, but even after all that, there was never really any offer to make it right. I would suggest a little more training in the customer service department. The server was never rude or anything, but for the money I paid, I would expect a higher level of service. 3- This place is expensive as pizza goes. It's good pizza, don't get me wrong, just be ready for the fact that it's pricier then other local pizza restaurants on the area. I gave it 3 stars for now. Over all, it's good food and a pleasant atmosphere.(Although we also experienced the wind as people came & went. This was mentioned in another review) I wouldn't order it every weekend, but certainly every couple of months