Atlantis Diner Restaurant in West Islip

Name: Atlantis Diner
Address: 350 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, United States
Telephone: 16315872003
Rating: 3.1

Owner not registered

Main

United States

Establishments

Atlantis Diner

Reviews

#27 From 43 in West Islip

6.2

10 Review

Ambience

6.2/10

Food

6.2/10

Interior

6.2/10

Prices

6.2/10

Service

6.2/10

More details

Price & Cuisine

$$ American

Establishment type

Restaurant

Features

Information

+16315872003

350 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, United States

Get direction

Website Atlantis Diner

About

It's worth coming to Atlantis Diner to try nicely cooked French onion soup, meat sandwiches and chef salads. Tasty biscuits, waffles and pancakes can be what you need. Drink good beer, it's a must when visiting this place. You will be offered good coffee. Food delivery is an important advantage of this spot. The atmosphere of hospitality of Atlantis Diner highly depends on the staff, that is cool here. Professional service is something that visitors note in their reviews. Delicious dishes at affordable prices are offered here. This place is famous for its cozy atmosphere. This spot has received Google 4.2 according to the guests' opinions.

Rating

Excellent

Very Good

Average

Poor

Terrible

Sorting

Newest

Oldest

Ascending rating

Descending rating

Date

Date From - Date To

Glider RS

Source:

A week ago

Small diner near Bay Shore. Went for a business lunch and the service was fast and food was decent. Service Dine in Meal type Lunch Price per person $10–20 Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 3

James Thompson

Food was great and service was good but other dinners had better prices Service Dine in

Michael Jarvis

2 weeks ago

My wife, son and I went here for the first time and the last. We went for breakfast, nothing crazy. Coffee, OJ, I got short stack pancakes and bacon, wife got eggs Benedict which came with potatoes and son got French toast with 2 scrambled eggs on the side. So to start for a diner, the coffee was not something you wanted a second cup of maybe top off but that’s it. Onto to eggs Benedict which is my wife’s usual order when we go out to breakfast where do I start … the “poached egg” was practically hard-boiled, the hollandaise sauce was definitely not fresh was definitely from a commercialized mix packet, the English muffin was hard to cut even with a steak knife and the “Canadian bacon” was ham. She wound up scraping off the sauce and removing the ham (which is whole purpose of eggs Benedict) and eating the rest. The only positive thing she can say is the potatoes were decent. Even the oj tasted watered down. The pancakes were on par with a store bought complete mix in a box and bacon was very greasy. The French toast was “meh” bread tasted like cheap bargain bread and did not have a grilled appearance (more like a premade frozen food aisle appearance). Then we looked up and saw a big hole in the ceiling above us with wet beams, insulation and ceiling tiles with mold and flies in it, nothing covering it and as we proceeded to leave a small piece of something from there fell into the booth next to us. The lighting fixture which was 2 tables over from us which had wallpaper and ornamental attributes was peeling and pieces were missing and looked like more is ready to drop. 1st and last time. There are so many other good diners maybe the owners should visit some of those and see how they can improve. Service Dine in Meal type Breakfast Price per person $10–20 Food: 1 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 2

Chopmeat Bobby

2 months ago

Just did a takeout order got a grilled cheese no french fries and a small soup. It was $19 and it was terrible. This place used to be consistent. Their food used to be great. The service used to be great now everything has changed. The manager or owner that always sits up by the counter. All he does is talk to people and leave you waiting there to pay Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

Alex Pinsker

We got seated quickly, even though we had a large group of people. Food took a little while but that is expected for fresh cooked food on busy morning. Portions were large and good tasting. Perfect diner experience. Meal type Brunch Price per person $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes 2 Eggs Any Style with Bacon

Tony Palmer

I’ve been to this diner a few times and this is the second time being treated with disrespect by staff. This time it was by management. I came into the diner with some family to have a business meeting over breakfast. the old woman with gray hair behind the counter was extremely rude and agitated when I asked if we could have two tables put together for the five people that were coming to meet us. I’ve worked in the restaurant industry for over 10 years and that kind of request would never bother me when the entire restaurant is empty. The gray haired woman behind the counter should be fired immediately and replaced with someone who is accommodating, friendly, and grateful for business. I won’t be back and you shouldn’t try this place. Service Dine in Meal type Breakfast Food: 2 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 2

Rachel Weitz

Where do I begin my husband and I were utterly shocked when we found out our favorite waiter is no longer there, we found out the daytime manager wrongfully fired him to make room for someone she knew, out of all people one of the sweetest young waiters we ever met was let go. We stopped going there for breakfast when we realized she was the daytime manager one of the rudest women you could ever meet. He was one of the most polite, kind and patient waiters we ever met if this is how this Diner runs a business and treats their employees I will make sure no one I know ever goes there again!!!!!! To do this in itself is despicable but around Christmas time makes it worse!!! Jonathan I hope you come across this review and know that Atlantis Diner has lost one of their most valuable employees. I will never be returning to that diner because I am heartbroken over this news. They should fire this woman immediately. Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

ally g

4 months ago

Easily accessible location with reasonably sized parking lot. Host (manager?) and server were very nice. Food was cooked correctly and we all enjoyed our meals. Huge portions. It’s pretty pricey but everything is nowadays and we like to support local businesses especially the old school diners. Service Dine in Meal type Brunch Price per person $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5

Jennifer Magioncalda

6 months ago

Great inside atmosphere. The Wait staff was very attentive. I went there specifically for the cheesecake shake because I heard it was delish. It did not disappoint. Service Dine in Meal type Dinner Price per person $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Rick White

8 months ago

This was an interesting experience. Kudos to Theresa for serving me and making this review better. The food was very good, and I would eat here again. I must say the waitress assigned to my table never acknowledged me, apologized for making me wait and not serving me, or even checking on me. Theresa, a manager took care of me with great service. If you read this Theresa, thank you!!... 6/16/2023.. I returned to have super and after waiting 30 minutes without being acknowledged I left. Meal type Breakfast Price per person $20–30 Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes 2 Eggs Any Style with Bacon