Discover Top Restaurants in Shelter Island - Updated 2024 - Eatagram

Main

United States

Shelter Island

Top restaurants in Shelter Island

See all

IGA Shelter Island

$

Bakery

75, North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, Shelter Island, United States

Léon 1909

$

International

29, West Neck Road, Shelter Island, Shelter Island, United States

Shelter Island Whale's Tale

$$$

International

3 Ram Island Rd, Shelter Island, United States

Shelter Island Slice

$

Pizza, Beer bars, Sandwiches

3 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, United States

Island Cafe

$

International

63, South Menantic Road, Shelter Island, Shelter Island, United States

New restaurants in Shelter Island

See all

IGA Shelter Island

$

Bakery

75, North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, Shelter Island, United States

Léon 1909

$

International

29, West Neck Road, Shelter Island, Shelter Island, United States

Shelter Island Whale's Tale

$$$

International

3 Ram Island Rd, Shelter Island, United States

Shelter Island Slice

$

Pizza, Beer bars, Sandwiches

3 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, United States

Island Cafe

$

International

63, South Menantic Road, Shelter Island, Shelter Island, United States

Shelter Island by type of cuisine